Low Carb Dietitian
  • Home
  • Book
  • About Me
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Research
  • Links
  • My Diet Doctor articles

Misrepresenting the Evidence on Low-Carb Diets

9/8/2013

14 Comments

 
PictureBurrata with heirloom tomatoes, arugula, olives, olive oil
While doing research for one of my Answers.com articles, Defending Your Low-Carb Diet, I found an interesting article on WebMD. I know that much of the information found online is critical of carb restriction, but I was unprepared for the claims made on this website, which is extremely popular and considered a trusted source by many Americans. 

First of all, the article discusses "high-protein, low-carbohydrate diets" and defines "high protein" as 30-50% of caloric intake. Aside from the Stillman diet and perhaps the diets of a few bodybuilders, I don't know of any other popular low-carb plans that recommend more than 30% of calories from protein. On a 2000-calorie diet, 30%  is 150 grams of protein, and 50% is 250 grams. Most low-carb diets are moderate in protein, although some people may consume higher amounts. This article purports to talk about the risks vs. benefits of high-protein, low-carbohydrate diets, but the "benefits" are glossed over, and several of the statements seem to denigrate carb restriction in particular. 

According to Web MD,  high-protein, low-carb diets can cause many health problems:
  • Kidney failure  This is untrue in the case of people with healthy kidneys. Although individuals with advanced kidney disease may need to restrict protein, there is no evidence that a high-protein, low-carb diet damages renal function (1).
  • High cholesterol  The article states "It is well known that high-protein diets (consisting of red meat, whole dairy products, and other high fat foods) are linked to high cholesterol. Studies have linked high cholesterol levels to an increased risk of developing heart disease, stroke, and cancer."  First off, low-carb diets don't always result in elevated cholesterol levels. And in the vast majority of cases, lipid profiles become more favorable in terms of particle size and number, improved HDL to cholesterol ratio, and lower triglycerides, resulting in less risk of cardiovascular disease and stroke. The exception would be people with familial hypercholesterolemia, who may need to limit dietary fat and cholesterol and replace most foods high in saturated fat with items containing monounsaturated fat like olive oil. With respect to cancer, older and recent research has demonstrated that it is associated with lower rather than higher cholesterol levels (2,3). 
  • Osteoporosis  Studies indicate this is not a concern with high protein consumption provided intake of   plants -- ie, nonstarchy vegetables -- is adequate (4).
  • Cancer  It's irritating to repeatedly read the assertion that low-carb diets don't provide vitamins, minerals, fiber, and antioxidants. There are loads of micronutrients in animal products, and the vegetables, berries, nuts, and avocado consumed on carbohydrate-restricted diets supply plenty of fiber and antioxidants.
  • Unhealthy metabolic state (ketosis)  The information on ketosis in this article was contradictory but predominantly negative. On the one hand, the benefits of ketosis (switching to fat burning, weight loss, reduced appetite) are discussed early in the article, but later:  "During ketosis, the body forms substances known as ketones, which can cause organs to fail and result in gout, kidney stones, or kidney failure." Where is the evidence for this statement?  Children with epilepsy following extremely low-carb ketogenic diets (about 10 grams of carb per day) were found to be at greater risk of developing kidney stones (5), but as far as I know, this hasn't been seen in adults following VLC diets that include nonstarchy vegetables and berries. As far as gout, people who already have the condition will need to continue to monitor their uric acid levels, and they would benefit from eating alkalizing plant foods like vegetables in addition to protein and fat. However, there is no evidence that ketogenic diets cause gout, and because this condition is  related to insulin resistance, outcomes may actually improve on a carb-restricted diet.  Finally, there is no evidence that ketogenic diets cause kidney failure; in fact, preliminary research suggests they may actually reverse kidney damage (6).

In the summary, "Is Low Carb Right for Me?" the writer states that carb restriction is dangerous, particularly for those with heart disease, and that low-carb diets don't allow a high intake of fruits and vegetables. I strongly disagree.  I believe this way of eating is beneficial for people with heart disease for the reasons listed above, as well  as improvements in hyperinsulinemia, hyperglycemia, and hypertension. And there are plenty of plant foods allowed on a low-carb diet. I eat vegetables at every meal, a few servings of nuts a day, berries once a day, and avocado just about every day on my VLC diet. I probably get more vegetables than most people do, along with more fiber and antioxidants. 

Although I guess I shouldn't be surprised, it concerns me that such a highly critical and inaccurate article was published on WebMD.  Perhaps there are even worse articles written on medical sites considered reputable? In my opinion, using scare tactics to discourage people from adopting a carbohydrate-restricted diet is troubling, particularly since this way of eating has had such a positive impact on a significant number of people and has the potential to improve the lives of so many others.

* Although low-carbohydrate diets are safe and healthy for most people, it's important to speak with your doctor prior to adopting a low-carb diet or making other dietary changes.

References:
1. Friedman AN, et al. Comparative effects of low-carbohydrate, high-protein vs. low-fat diets on the kidney. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol. 2012 Jul;7(7):1103-11
2. Kritchevsky SB, et al. Serum cholesterol and cancer risk: an epidemiologic perspective. Annu Rev Nutr. 1992; 12:391-416.
3. Strohmaier S, et al. Total serum cholesterol and caner incidence in the metabolic syndrome and cancer project (ME-CAN).J Epidemiol Community Health 2011; 65:A302 doi:10.1136/jech.2011 
4. Barzel US, et al. Excessive dietary protein can adversely affect bone. J Nutr 128:1051-1053, 1988
5. Sampath A, et al. Kidney stones and the ketogenic diet: risk factors and prevention. J Child Neurol. 2007 April:22(4):375-378
6. Poplawski MM, et al. Reversal of nephropathy by a ketogenic diet. PLoS One 6:1–9, 2011


14 Comments
Randy Hebert link
9/7/2013 10:58:06 pm

I appreciate your attack of the mainstream media, Web MD, I probably trust them myself too much.
I would like you to review the Hart Dietary Procedure and later give you my testimony. I am a cancer survivor.

Reply
Franziska Spritzler link
9/8/2013 03:38:16 am

Thanks so much for your comments, Randy. Congratulations on being a cancer survivor. Can you please provide me with a link to information regarding the Hart Dietary Procedure (the link to your website didn't work). You can use the "Contact Me" page if you like.

Reply
Randy Hebert
9/8/2013 05:10:19 am

Www.ColJoe.com
Its the address I left in my previous comment in the website block.
Thanks!

Franziska Spritzler link
9/8/2013 09:31:59 am

Sorry, Randy. I still get an error message when I try to access Www.ColJoe.com.

Gerri
9/8/2013 12:33:38 pm

Thanks for setting the record straight point by incorrect point. So much for WedMD being a credible source.

Reply
Franziska Spritzler link
9/8/2013 09:16:37 pm

Thanks, Gerri!

Reply
Dan Brown link
9/8/2013 09:56:05 pm

Your frustration and anger are palpible, Franziska. It is lamentable, no shameful, and STUPID that a 'usually' (?) reputable site, WebMD, would risk their credibility by publishing such irresponsible garbage. Their insistance that this WOE is 'high protein,' which you pick up on right away, is the prime example: As you say, I know of NO low-carb advocate that recommends a diet of more than 30% protein, and most of us eat I think between 20 and 25% protein. That being said I read a peer-reviewed study years ago (unfortunately, lost to me) that most Americans eat 15% (women) and 16% (men) protein (average). Of course, the proverbial 2,000kcal. diet on the Nutrition Facts Panel on packaged and processed food is based on 10% protein (50g = 200kcal). It was probably constructed by a vegan.

Reply
Franziska Spritzler link
9/8/2013 11:27:25 pm

Thanks so much for your comments and continued support, Dan! I know there are many writers at WebMD, and most seem to research topics thoroughly before writing articles, but unfortunately that wasn't the case here. Protein needs vary from individual to individual, but >30% is unnecessarily high and 10% is definitely too low, in my opinion.

Reply
Tim
9/9/2013 08:06:53 pm

When I see a low carb diet described as high protein I quit reading. If the author doesn't know enough to describe it as high fat/ low carb any "facts' presented are automatically called into question.

Reply
Franziska Spritzler link
9/9/2013 09:16:17 pm

Great policy, Tim. Thanks for your comments.

Reply
Steve Parker, M.D. link
9/29/2013 12:18:21 am

Franziska, I can't think of anything you wrote above that I would disagree with.

The WebMD article was reviewed by an internist in 2012. It's hard for me to believe she did a thorough review of the recent pertinent scientific literature. Many of her points were mainstream in 2002, but we've learned much since then.

-Steve

Reply
Franziska Spritzler link
9/29/2013 02:40:55 am

Appreciate and agree with your comments, Steve!

Reply
Janknitz
10/4/2013 01:00:17 am

Exactly! Low carb "high protein" is a hold over from the 1990's when the low carb gurus were too afraid to emphasize that it was high fat. Other than a few outliers like the Weston A Price group, most people did not recognize that natural fats are healthful and full of vitamins we NEED. It was simply too politically incorrect to mention the fat.

Reply
Franziska Spritzler link
10/4/2013 04:50:24 am

Thanks so much for your comments, Janknitz. Fat phobia is rampant among many in the medical and nutrition fields. I continue to hope that this will change.


Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Author 

    Franziska Spritzler, RD, CDE

    Categories

    All
    Academy Of Nutrition And Dietetics
    American Diabetes Association
    Answers.com Articles
    Authority Nutrition Articles
    Bone-health
    Bpa
    Calories
    Cardiovascular Disease
    Dairy
    Diabetes
    Dietetic Associations
    Fiber
    High Fat
    Hyperinsulinemia
    Inflammation
    Insulin Resistance
    Introduction
    Ketogenic Diets
    Low Carb
    Muscle Mass
    Net Carbs
    Paleo
    PCOS
    Primal
    Protein
    Quick Low Carb Treats
    Quick Low-Carb Treats
    Recommended Reading
    Restaurants
    Reviews
    Saturated Fat
    Seafood
    Sugar Addiction
    Thanksgiving
    Thyroid
    Veganism
    Weight Management
    Weston A. Price Foundation

    Archives

    July 2019
    March 2019
    January 2019
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    November 2012
    October 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    March 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011

    RSS Feed

  • Home
  • Book
  • About Me
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Research
  • Links
  • My Diet Doctor articles